GadgetRoost is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. This does not change our recommendations. Learn more.
The best countertop water filter replacement filter is the genuine part made for your system, so it seals properly and keeps the maker’s certifications.
We compared 5 genuine replacements by fit and rated life.
Quick Answer: The Best Countertop Water Filter Replacement Filter
- Best for Brita Dispensers: Brita Elite Replacement Water Filter, 2 Pack
- Best for Berkey: Authentic Black Berkey Elements BB9-2 Filters, Set of 2
- Best for PUR Plus: PUR PLUS Faucet Mount Replacement Filter 2-Pack, RF99992
- Best Berkey Add-On: Berkey PF-2 Fluoride and Arsenic Reduction Elements, Set of 2
- Best Swap-Day Kit: Holikme Bottle Brush Tube Cleaning Set with Long Handle
Brita Elite Replacement Filters, 2-Pack are our best countertop water filter replacement filter for Brita dispensers. Black Berkey BB9-2 Elements (Pair) fit Berkey systems, and the PUR Plus Faucet Replacement Filter 2-Pack fits PUR Plus.
Best Countertop Water Filter Replacement Filter Comparison Table
| Product | Best For | Type | Key Feature | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brita Elite Replacement Water Filter, 2 Pack | Best for Brita Dispensers | Pitcher/dispenser filter | 120 gal or about 6 months each | Check Price |
| Authentic Black Berkey Elements BB9-2 Filters, Set of 2 | Best for Berkey | Gravity replacement elements | Up to 6,000 gal per pair (maker claim) | Check Price |
| PUR PLUS Faucet Mount Replacement Filter 2-Pack, RF99992 | Best for PUR Plus | Faucet replacement filter | 100 gal or 3 months each | Check Price |
| Berkey PF-2 Fluoride and Arsenic Reduction Elements, Set of 2 | Best Berkey Add-On | Add-on post-filter | 1,000 gal, used with Black Berkey | Check Price |
| Holikme Bottle Brush Tube Cleaning Set with Long Handle | Best Swap-Day Kit | Cleaning brushes | 16 in long brush + tube brushes | Check Price |
The 5 Best Countertop Water Filter Replacement Filters
Each pick below was compared on certifications, filter type, capacity, filter life and value.
Brita Elite Replacement Water Filter, 2 Pack
1Brita Elite filters are WQA NSF/ANSI certified to reduce 99% of lead, microplastics and chlorine, according to Brita.
👍 Pros & Cons
Pros
- Certified to reduce 99% of lead (maker claim)
- Lasts about 6 months
- Fits Brita pitchers and dispensers
Cons
- Slower flow than standard
📄 Detailed Review
- Type: Pitcher/dispenser filter
- Includes: 2 filters
- Key feature: 120 gal or about 6 months each
Each lasts 120 gallons or about 6 months.
It is our dispenser replacement pick.
Check Brita Elite Replacement Filters, 2-Pack Price on Amazon
Authentic Black Berkey Elements BB9-2 Filters, Set of 2
2Authentic Black Berkey BB9-2 elements fit Big Berkey, Berkey Light, Crown and Imperial systems.
👍 Pros & Cons
Pros
- Authentic Berkey elements
- Long life per pair
- Fits Big, Light, Crown and Imperial
Cons
- Must be primed
📄 Detailed Review
- Type: Gravity replacement elements
- Includes: 2 elements
- Key feature: Up to 6,000 gal per pair (maker claim)
Berkey says a pair lasts up to 6,000 gallons before replacement.
It is our gravity replacement pick.
PUR PLUS Faucet Mount Replacement Filter 2-Pack, RF99992
3Genuine PUR Plus replacement filters fit PUR Plus faucet systems.
👍 Pros & Cons
Pros
- Genuine PUR fit
- Mineral core
- About 6 months per pack
Cons
- Faucet-mount only
📄 Detailed Review
- Type: Faucet replacement filter
- Includes: 2 filters
- Key feature: 100 gal or 3 months each
Each filter is rated for up to 100 gallons or about 3 months.
It is our faucet replacement pick.
Check PUR Plus Faucet Replacement Filter 2-Pack Price on Amazon
Berkey PF-2 Fluoride and Arsenic Reduction Elements, Set of 2
4Berkey PF-2 elements are designed to work with Black Berkey elements to reduce fluoride and arsenic, according to Berkey.
👍 Pros & Cons
Pros
- Targets fluoride and arsenic (maker claim)
- Screws under Black Berkey elements
- Authentic Berkey part
Cons
- Extra cost and upkeep
📄 Detailed Review
- Type: Add-on post-filter
- Includes: 2 elements
- Key feature: 1,000 gal, used with Black Berkey
Berkey recommends replacing them after 1,000 gallons.
It is our add-on stage pick.
Holikme Bottle Brush Tube Cleaning Set with Long Handle
5Holikme’s set includes a 16-inch long brush, a 10-inch sponge brush and thin tube brushes.
👍 Pros & Cons
Pros
- Long 16 in brush
- Tube and straw brushes
- Soft sponge brush
Cons
- Not for filter media
📄 Detailed Review
- Type: Cleaning brushes
- Includes: Brush set
- Key feature: 16 in long brush + tube brushes
Use them on reservoirs, spigots and carafes, not on filter elements.
It is our cleaning-kit pick.
How We Chose the Best Countertop Water Filter Replacement Filter
To choose the best countertop water filter replacement filter, we compared popular gravity, countertop reverse osmosis, faucet-mount, dispenser and pitcher filters on Amazon by certifications, stages, capacity and owner feedback.
CDC says to test your water, check NSF certifications and change filters as the maker recommends; see the CDC guide to choosing home water filters.
Product details in this guide are based on manufacturer specifications and verified owner feedback. Read more on our How We Test page.
Buying Guide: Getting the Right Replacement
Keep these points in mind before you buy.
Genuine parts keep certifications
PUR notes off-brand filters may fit but are not certified to work with its systems; Berkey warns about lookalike BB9-2 filters.
Change filters with care
CDC says to change filters as the maker recommends, wear gloves and wash your hands afterward.
Read the NSF standards
CDC suggests looking for NSF certification on the label: Standard 42 covers taste and odor, 53 cyst reduction, 58 reverse osmosis and 62 distillation.
Replacement Tips
Fit it right:
- Check the model number.
- Buy from the brand listing.
- Flush before use.
- Reset the indicator.
Quick answers about the best countertop water filter replacement filter.
- Model number
- Brand listing
- Flush before use
- Reset indicator
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best countertop water filter replacement filter?
The best countertop water filter replacement filter is the genuine part: Brita Elite for Brita, Black Berkey for Berkey and PUR Plus refills for PUR.
Can I use off-brand filters?
Makers warn they may not be certified.
How do I know my model?
Check the system label or manual.
Do I need to flush new filters?
Most makers say yes.
Should I wear gloves?
CDC recommends gloves when changing filters.
Final Verdict
Our final pick for the best countertop water filter replacement filter is the Brita Elite Replacement Filters, 2-Pack. Choose the Black Berkey BB9-2 Elements (Pair) if you want Berkey systems, or the PUR Plus Faucet Replacement Filter 2-Pack to fit PUR Plus.
Related Guides
More water filter guides:
- Best Countertop Water Filter
- Best Countertop Water Filter for the Money
- Best Countertop Water Filter Pre Filter
- Best Refrigerator Organizer Replacement Filter
- Best Vacuum Food Containers
Product details are based on manufacturer specifications at the time of writing. Prices and availability change often, so check Amazon for the latest price.
Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!